Sunday, November 22, 2026

Cleveland Guardians owed David Fry a fair chance to prove what he could do, instead Fry has been non-tendered.

In 2024, David Fry would have a breakout first half of the season with the Cleveland Guardians.  Fry was 6th in all of baseball in OPS amongst batters with at least 150 at bats.

                                             David Fry's breakout 2024 Season. 

In mid June of 2024, Fry's breakout season would start to spin out of control due to an elbow injury. Good man Fry had been so intent on proving his worth, David Fry carried 4 gloves for every game. Equally impressive, and in retrospect possibly a mistake, Fry either was, or was not using various throwing motions and throwing angles from being switched all over the field, The unintended consequence was David Fry's throwing elbow began acting up, resulting in elbow surgery, Around 9 months after surgery, around mid July of 2025, Fry was deemed healthy. However, David Fry did not instantly return to his early season 2024 form. 

Just when David Fry might make 2025 playoff magic as he had done in 2024, a late September, 2025, 99 mph Tarik Skubal fastball to David Fry's upper mouth and nose on an ever so slightly deflected bunt attempt sent Fry down in a heap. 

Somewhat ironic, yet understandable, was Power hitter David Fry's willingness to bunt against a 99 mph Tarik Skubal fastball. David Fry's 2 year old daughter would wear a face bandaid to the Hospital to match her Daddy's bandage, which would heal that offseason. Total team player and quality guy David Fry came into  2026 Spring Training finally ready to contribute, by being 100% healthy.

But several things happened on the way to David Fry's potential 2026, full season break as Fry would be healthy and available to play right field, first base, catcher, and also sub for Jose Ramirez at third base when necessary. 

The good news for 2026 was Fry and the Guardians coaching staff had strategically figured out a way to simply Fry's throwing motion, so in theory Fry would be ready to play multiple positions in 2026, if necessary, with a much less threat to his elbow.

However, from a buffet of several positions to play, Fry basically got nothing. Chase Delauter became the quasi full time right fielder, Austin Hedges was having a breakout offensive year at catcher so good it matched Hedge's best effort from 10 years earlier. Incredibly, sub .200 hitter Austin Hedges was leading the Guardians in batting average for the first 8 weeks of the 2026 season. Bo Naylor was given extra time at catcher to see if Bo could finally get his hitting stroke going. Right off the bat, 2 positions that were meant for David Fry, right field and catcher, were drying up. While the right field and catcher scenarios that led to loss of playing time for David Fry (haven't even discussed the Patrick Bailey trade), it was the 2026 Spring Training Rhy Hoskins signing that prevent Fry from having a breakout 2026 season.

Rhys Hoskins, who had been to the World Series and whom the Guardians front office felt would be the positive veteran presence at first base and DH. Incredibly, David Fry had had a more impactful playoff appearances than Hoskins. Hoskins reached the World Series in 2022 and had a stat line of 3-for-25 (.120 AVG) with 1 home run, 1 RBI, 2 runs, and 10 strikeouts. Rhy Hoskins at first base over David Fry, seriously? The Guardians front office should have publicly apologized to Cleveland Fans for depriving good guy David Fry with an opportunity to man first base with Kyle Manzardo in a platoon role. What was even more frustrating, Manzardo was NOT in shape when he came to spring training. To Manzardo's credit, Manzardo did take all of April taking extra fielding practice and did make key defensive catches on poor infield throws in close, 9th inning games. But still, why did it take a month for Manzardo to get in shape? 

Rhys Hoskins was unable to eclipse a .200 batting average, which was statistically rationalized because Hoskins led the league in extra base hits for batters hitting under .200. (yes, that is a stat). 

Hoskins did manage to get just enough walks with his league leading extra base hits for batters hitting under .200 to make the Guardians stick with Hoskins all way through the end of July 2026. 

The problem that I saw on two occasions, and also read about a third occasion, (and there could have been more), Hoskins would openly show up his teammates ON THE FIELD right after a play would occur that irritated Hoskins, such as a bounced throw to first base twice irked Hoskins and made the news for how he immediately reacted to the bounced throw. 

The Rhys Hoskins free agent signing during spring training would effectively end Fry's productive time in Cleveland, although to be fair, the reality of David Fry not getting a fair chance did not fully vest until the trade for catcher Patrick Bailey of the San Francisco Giants.

In another instance, a runner did not score from 2nd base on a single by Hoskins. It was a situational issue, Guardians were up by several runs, the ball was hit hard by Hoskins and right at the left fielder, the runner at 2nd had to momentarily pause to make sure the ball went through the infield. The play at home would have been very close, the kind of play that could lead to an injury if the baserunner slides into the catcher, who would have had time to set up fir the tag with enough time to position themselves in front of home plate, without having to worry about a blocking home plate infraction. Since the Guardians were already up several runs, there was no need to send the player on such a close play at home. Hoskins publicly gestured from first base as to why the runner had not scored from 2nd base, hence, no RBI.

These were the actions of a veteran presence the Cleveland Guardians selected over Playoff hero David Fry, who before his "multiple position playing injuries", was top five in OPS in the MLB after the first 2 and 1/2 months of the 2024 season.

Nonetheless, The Guardians front office choosing Rhy Hoskins over David Fry at first base in 2026 will in my opinion, be one of the dumbest, botched, anti fan moves the Cleveland Guardians have made since Rocky Colavito. Fry earned and deserved a chance at first base in 2026.  

Fry was optioned to the minors at the 2026 trade deadline and hit home runs in six straight games, was called backed to the majors, and once again sat on the bench.  

The Guardians, rather than admit they screwed over David Fry and giving Fry a chance at first base in 2027 as a veteran presence for up and coming minor league talents Ralphy Velasquez, Kody Huff, and even the possible return of Kyle Manzardo, have doubled down by not tendering Fry a contract offer for the 2027 season.  As a birthday present, Fry was released on his birthday!

Whatever "Sad to see Fry go article one's read on the internet", NONE will chastize the Cleveland Guardians front office for going to the veteran bin from another baseball team for a shiny veteran presence, when the Guardians already had that player ready and raring to go in on their roster named David Fry. 

I sincerely hope Fry is given a chance to play first base somewhere in MLB. Fry would be a steal at 5 million a year for 3 years. 

Los Angeles Emmy winning Producer Alessandro Machi combines his editing, camera, math, and real time action observational skills to provide unique insights into the World of Sports.

No comments:

Post a Comment

My present nerd stat project is a credit card product that would reverse the consumer credit card debt record of 1.1 trillion dollars. If you can connect me to a credit card company concerned about America's Consumer Credit Card Debt, then we could be partners.